Pizza & Sub Shoppe

Discover delicious calzones, hearty meatball subs, and more at Pizza & Sub Shoppe in Mill Creek, WV. Enjoy our cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and historic setting. Call us today at +1 304-335-6518!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Pizza & Sub Shoppe

Experience the finest dining

Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe

Pizza & Sub Shoppe welcomes food lovers with a blend of tradition and taste. Nestled along US-219 in Mill Creek, WV, this cozy eatery boasts a rich history reflected in its charming decor. The moment you step inside, the friendly staff greets you with smiles, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. This spot is perfect for anyone craving a delicious meal, whether it's a hearty calzone, an irresistible meatball sub, or one of their specialty pizzas. The tantalizing aromas from the open kitchen dance in the air, making it hard to resist trying something new.

The variety on the menu ensures there's something for everyone, from classic favorites to unique creations. With a focus on cleanliness and customer satisfaction, Pizza & Sub Shoppe guarantees a memorable dining experience that locals cherish.

Pizza & Sub Shoppe shines with its diverse menu, featuring 57 delectable dishes. Patrons love the 8" oven-toasted pizza bread options, harboring flavors that delight the palate. Choose from the savory ham and cheese, turkey, or crispy chicken subs, all perfect for a filling meal on the go. For those looking for something heartier, the calzones are a must-try, available in delightful varieties like meat lover's and bacon beef.

Sides like curly fries and jalapeno poppers complement any meal, but the real showstopper remains the meatball sub, rich with flavor and comfort. The restaurant’s historic charm amplifies the dining experience, with warm woodwork and a cozy vibe that resonates with the local community. Frequent tours are available to share the stories and history behind this unique establishment, making it a local treasure.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

US-219, Mill Creek, WV 26280, United States

Phone

+1 304-335-6518

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe
Pizza & Sub Shoppe

Pizza & Sub Shoppe stands as a beloved cornerstone in Mill Creek, West Virginia. Established to fulfill the cravings of locals and visitors alike, this eatery emphasizes quality and flavor in every dish. It showcases an impressive menu with 57 items, ensuring something for every appetite. The sub selection is extensive, with cold cuts available in both 6" and 12" sizes. Signature items like the cheeseburger sub and pepperoni & cheese pizza blend classic flavors with a twist, catering to diverse tastes. The homey feel of the restaurant makes it a great meeting place for families, friends, and travelers exploring the scenic surroundings of Mill Creek.

The staff goes above and beyond to create a friendly, welcoming atmosphere that keeps patrons returning day after day. Each meal is prepared with care, reflecting a commitment to freshness and satisfaction. Visitors rave about the cleanliness and attention to detail, adding to the overall experience. Whether dining in, taking out, or enjoying a tour of the historic building, customers feel connected to a piece of local history while indulging in scrumptious cuisine. For anyone in Mill Creek looking for a delightful meal, Pizza & Sub Shoppe is the go-to destination.

Pizza & Sub Shoppe

Pizza & Sub Shoppe captures the essence of Mill Creek with its charming exterior. Housed in a historic building, its traditional architecture draws attention and evokes nostalgia. Outdoor seating provides a perfect setting for enjoying a meal while taking in the sights and sounds of the community. The vibrant vibe mixes with the warmth of the surrounding neighborhood, making it a perfect spot to gather with friends or unwind after a day of exploring. The cozy interior complements the exterior charm, enveloping visitors in a friendly embrace that invites them to stay.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Saturday3-8:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We were a little skeptical at first, but I'm SO glad we went! The restaurant is clean and I love that it's in an older home where they kept the woodwork! The employees were friendly and made us feel welcome. The food was good! I ordered a Meat Lovers Calzone and it was STUFFED with meat and tasted amazing. Will definitely eat here again!

J
Judith D.

Me and my friends were driving back from a long week on skiing and snowboarding. We were stuck in the mountains incredibly hungry until we found this place. Absolutely incredible food and great service

V
Vinnie R.

My wife and I stopped by on Saturday night and ordered a Hawaiian pizza. The owner also gave us a small BLT pizza to sample! The food there is absolutely delicious. The employees and owner are as friendly as can be. Definitely recommend stopping on your next trip.

D
Duke P.

Tasty, affordable fare in a gorgeous 19th century home, converted into a kitchen and restaurant serving locals and travelers alike. Meatball sub was on point and the Philly cheese was the same. Can't go wrong with sweet tea. Thank you to Ron for the tour and to the staff for a delicious break in our trip!

M
Michael G.

Very friendly staff. Good service, and clean. Would definitely recommend it for pizza if you are in the area.

M
Mike P.

The best pizza in town! Friendly service, and if you're not in a hurry, dine in! You'll be looking not only the history of mill creek when you set down but historic items as well.

S
SHEENA W.